When a civil court has to decide who leaked a private message, it rarely gets a confession. What it gets instead are logs, settings screens, and silence where evidence should be, and sometimes a phone that simply isn’t there anymore. The 2022 English libel trial the press nicknamed “Wagatha Christie” (formally Vardy v Rooney [2022] EWHC 2017 (QB), heard in the High Court of Justice, Queen’s Bench Division) is worth a second look by Israeli practitioners, not for its celebrity cast but for the quiet mechanics underneath: how a social-media platform’s own access controls became evidence, and what a court does when the one device that could settle everything has vanished.
The dispute began with a trap. Coleen Rooney publicly stated that an Instagram account belonging to Rebekah Vardy had been leaking the content of Rooney’s private Instagram stories to the tabloid The Sun. Vardy denied this and sued Rooney for libel. But Rooney hadn’t just suspected a leak. She had tested for one. She blocked every follower from viewing her Instagram stories except one account, Vardy’s, then posted fabricated stories and watched to see whether they would surface in The Sun. Her own screenshots showed the planted stories “Seen by 1,” and the court found that one viewer was Vardy’s account. The evidentiary point matters: if a story that only one account could see later turns up in a tabloid, the platform’s own permission structure has effectively run a controlled experiment on her behalf. It narrows the universe of possible sources down to a single node. Lawyers who are used to arguing about who said what to whom through oral testimony find themselves, in this fact pattern, litigating something stranger: a configuration setting. Who had technical visibility into a given piece of content, and when. That is a different species of evidence, and it cannot be gathered, interpreted, or presented the way a witness statement is.
Then came the part that should make any litigator sit up. Vardy’s agent and close friend, Caroline Watt, said her phone went overboard during a family boat trip in Scotland in August 2021, days after the court had ordered that device inspected. The phone was simply gone: not deleted, not seized, lost over the side of a boat. Together with the loss of Vardy’s own copy, this meant the full WhatsApp chat between Vardy and Watt was unavailable to the court. English civil procedure does not simply shrug at a vanished exhibit. The judge found it “likely” that Watt dropped the phone deliberately, and that Vardy deliberately deleted her copy of the chat. She held that where a party has parted with relevant evidence, the court may draw adverse inferences, and she did, inferring that Vardy and Watt had leaked more than the posts directly proven. The practical lesson for a litigator: “the phone is gone” is not where the evidentiary conversation ends. It can be exactly where an inference against the party who controlled, and lost, the device begins.
Why this needs a digital forensics expert witness
Reading an Instagram visibility setting correctly, knowing what “only visible to this account” actually guarantees about exposure and, just as importantly, what it does not, is not intuitive. Neither is reconstructing a device’s custody history once it has slipped out of the record entirely. The court ultimately found that Rooney’s allegation against Vardy was “substantially true,” and Vardy lost the libel claim, with judgment given on 29 July 2022. The outcome turned on inferential fact-finding built from platform mechanics and an evidentiary gap: exactly the terrain where a forensic expert, rather than counsel’s own reading of a screenshot, is the one who determines whether an inference actually holds.
That is the same discipline a source code expert witness brings to a repository dispute: logs can be edited, timestamps can mislead, and a party who parted with a device has usually left some other trace an expert knows how to read. Explaining what a configuration setting proves, what it does not, and how a court should weigh a conspicuous gap in the record is expert work, not a lawyer’s own read of a screenshot.